I’ve been reading this article, and the comments posted along with it. The essential idea behind the article is that the author feels a little “uneasy” with the fact that veterinary medicine has improved, and thus the length of a pet’s life can be increased, often with a large price tag. “I think I’d be a better person to let my animal die naturally and then give $1,000 to combat child poverty, or even animal abuse.” And many of the comments, at their core, reflect the sentiment that people deserve advanced medicine, while animals do not… as well, people are better than animals.
Somehow I feel that it is necessary to respond to this in some sort of way, as many of you are aware from me telling stories, my cat has had extensive surgeries, at a cost of upwards of three thousand dollars. And since the surgery he has been required to eat a special diet of prescription pet food. At around four years old, my cat was diagnosed with Feline Lower Urinary Tract Disease. He was unable to urinate due to blockage, and was brought to the vet several times to be catheterized, in order to empty his bladder, and to clear the blockage. Unfortunately these measures were unsuccessful, and we had to bring our cat late in the evening to an emergency veterinary facility in Hartford, a forty-five minute drive. We were told that toxins were building up in his system, death was imminent, he might not even survive the trip to the hospital. At the hospital we had to make a decision: emergency surgery, or euthanasia.
Let me just say this: if your child needs surgery, there is no way in hell that you are ever forced to make a decision for surgery based on economics, you either pay for it, or we let your kid die. I suppose this is where the issue gets touchy. Euthanasia is acceptable for pets, it is not for people. I will say that I don’t totally agree with that idea. For an old, sick, animal, (or for that matter a person) with a low quality of life, I see euthanasia as an acceptable option. However, my four-year-old cat hardly fit into that category. The average lifespan for an indoor house cat is around fifteen years, and so I reasoned he had significant time left to live. Ending a life, any life, due solely to economics seems wrong to me.
We opted for an emergency perineal urethrostomy: the necessary surgery to save my cat’s life. His penis was removed, and his genitalia were reconstructed to prevent future blockages; he essentially had a sex change. I attempt to explain this to people and generally they think I am a dipshit and I don’t quite understand what happens when a cat gets neutered. I do wonder about what exactly would happen if my cat were to go missing and I made a poster… list him as a male, or female? Nomatter, my cat is now celebrating his tenth birthday. He has lived six years since his surgery and is in wonderful health. There is no doubt in my mind that he will live many more happy years.
As I sort of draw my little quasi rant (that likely no one will read) to a close, I will step away from the possible open door of making a statement about religion; it tends to be my experience that people who clearly view human life more important than anything else as religious. I will also ignore the “normally intelligent” comment by the author, which seems to imply that they view pet owners that believe that the value of a pet’s life with the same respect as a human life, as stupid.
Was it worth spending more than three thousand dollars for a surgery to prolong my cat’s life? I say, hell yes. I view the life of my pet and his right to live equal as that of any person. Would it be acceptable to allow a person to “die naturally?” What in the heck does that even mean anyways? If you want to get right down to it, if we lived “naturally” I’d have died as a kid, picked off by predators. I’m scrawny as heck, with horrible vision. If we lived “naturally” I’d be dead, and not ever have the chance to reproduce: the “better” humans would. We don’t live naturally, we do, however, live based upon our morals. Failing to give medical care I just don’t think is morally right, human, feline, canine or otherwise.